Showing posts with label Twin Cities RISE. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Twin Cities RISE. Show all posts

Tuesday

"The Non Nonprofit" by Steve Rothschild

A friend recommended "The Non Nonprofit" by Steve Rothschild and I'm glad he did, because the book takes a completely different approach to the problem of paying for social services from anything else I have read. The book is organized around seven principles, with an additional chapter about how important it is to put the principles into practice together.

Rothschild is a former executive at General Mills who went on to use his business experience, acumen, and connections to form a nonprofit, Twin Cities RISE!, whose purpose is to reduce concentrated poverty. Notice the use of the word purpose where you might expect to see mission. Organizations need both, Rothschild explains. Purpose guides programming, reinforces a long-term perspective, and encourages flexibility and innovation. Mission, on the other hand, is concrete. It sets out what the organization does (and does not) do; it puts the purpose into operation. Rothschild's first principle? "Have a clear and appropriate purpose."

The other principles are worth bearing in mind also - measure what counts, be market driven, create mutual accountability, support personal empowerment, and be learning driven. All good things, and Rothschild's take on them, particularly the mutual accountability and personal empowerment sections, are worth reading. Alert readers will have notice that so far I have mentioned only six principles.

The seventh is "Create Economic Value from Social Benefit." In this chapter, Rothschild argues that since every improvement in social good creates social value it is up to nonprofits to quantify who is receiving the value and what it is worth. As he puts it, our current approach to financing social service work "doesn't make sense." Why not? We have big problems, but pay small organizations to deal with them. The problems are systemic, but we spend money in one to two year cycles. Nonprofits focused on these issues don't have access to the long-term capital that for-profits do.

Rothschild outlines two alternative approaches to what he calls the "no financial return expected" approach - the one that government and philanthropic funders use now. These approaches go beyond performance based contracting as it is practiced now. Both depend on calculating a firm and credible return on investment.

I have discussed one of the alternatives, social impact bonds, here (as well as its cousin health impact bonds, here.) Rothschild's alternative, and he appears to have invented the concept (and founded an organization that worked for passage of a Minnesota law to try it out), is the Human Capital performance bond. One explanation of Human Capital Bonds is:
Human Capital Performance Bonds . . . are State AA "annual appropriation" bonds that fund high-performing human services.
The bonds pay market rates, and might be bought by private investors, financial institutions, or social investors. As Rothschild puts it:
The basic mechanism of the [human capital bond] is simple: if the social outcomes that a nonprofit generates create economic value that is greater than the state's cost of borrowing the funds, then the state will have both a social and economic incentive to sell the bonds.
Here's a diagram of how it works:


Human Capital bonds have yet to come into existence, even in Minnesota, and there are lots of questions remaining to be answered. For one interesting take, see this article.

Monday

Using Outcome Measures

While some sectors of the not-for-profit world have been using outcome measures for many years, others providers are still doubtful about the benefits and costs of using them. What are outcome measures? Outcome measures are simply standards that a program's staff sets to determine whether the program is accomplishing what it exists to accomplish.

So what is an outcome? It's a benefit or change for participating individuals or populations during or after the program's activities. For a foster care program, an outcome might be reducing length of stay in placement. For an HIV prevention program, it might be reducing the number of new infections. (Note: While these are simple statements, developing and calculating the outcomes should be a considered process. That will be the subject of a later post.)

The advantages of using carefully thought through outcome measures are many. For example, you can use them with outsiders in some of the follow ways.
  • Once you have outcome measures, you can state clearly what you have accomplished. For example, Twin Cities RISE, a program designed to provide employers with skilled workers - mostly men from communities of color -  states on its website that people who complete its programs increase their annual income by over 355%, and 70% remain employed in the second year after placement.
  • Using outcome measures lets all stakeholders know what your expectations for service providers are. For example, in New York City the Administration for Children's Services Scorecard sets out a detailed process of review, rating and rebuttal for providers of foster care and preventive services. You can download a copy of the Scorecard methodology here.
  • More and more, funders like government and foundations are requiring outcome measures,  are basing funding decisions on prior outcomes, or letting performance-based contracts. In addition, accrediting agencies often require outcome measures. Having a system in place means access to more funding opportunities.
Sometimes directors or managers believe that they don't have time, or staff, or money to develop or use outcome measures, or that their clients or services are too specialized to make generalizations possible. They're wrong. There are also many internal reasons to develop and use outcome measures:
  • Your staff can see whether their efforts really make a difference in people's lives. 
  • If not, then staff are in a position to suggest changes or improvements to programs.
  • You can target effective services for expansion or replication.
  • You can compare program performance from year to year.
This post is part of a series about developing and using high quality management indicators.You can see related posts here and here.

Popular Posts